Nation STATion: Nine questions facing the Red Sox


Nation STATion: Nine questions facing the Red Sox

By Bill Chuck
Special to

Watching postseason action might have Red Sox Nation thinking about what could have been and what should have been. It was only made worse on Tuesday when Adrian Beltre went deep three times and Victor Martinez hit his own homer. However, the focus has to be on what will be. Que sera?

To sum up where we stand right now:
Red Sox have no manager.
The general manager may be leaving.
We have a number of free agents in critical positions.
And, we have a number of pitchers who drink in the clubhouse and stink on the mound.

With all that in mind, here are nine questions to ponder:
1. Who will provide the Sox with right-hand power?
Red Sox batters hit .274 this season, second only to the Rangers .287. However, the Rangers righties hit 149 homers to lead the league and the Sox righties only hit 71, good for 10th in the league. The power drop from last year was significant as righties his 126 homers for the Sox in 2010. Not only that, but Sox righties had only 612 hits (11th in the league) down from 949 last season.

2. What will the Sox do behind the plate?
Red Sox catchers led the AL with 29 homers, but their .229 batting average was only good for the ninth in the league. Making matters worse, Boston catchers led the AL with 189 strikeouts, 99 more than White Sox catchers, who had the fewest whiffs. Jarrod Saltalamacchia ended up at only .235 but did hit 16 homers. He struck out once every 3.0 at bats.

The big question is who will share Saltys slot? Jason Varitek is the captain, and he has great knowledge about the pitching staff. The problem is that even that even though he hit 11 homers, as good as he is behind the plate, he is a liability at the plate. His .221 batting average raised his average over the last four seasons to .218. From July 8 to the end of the season, 'Tek played 28 games and hit .184 and had a .252 OBP. In September, he hit .077. Ryan Lavarnway does not yet have great skills behind the plate, but this season in the minors he hit .290 with 32 homers and 93 RBI and he is a right-hand hitter.

3. Why are the 1st innings so bad for Sox pitchers?
The three worst 1st inning pitching staffs: Baltimore starters allowed 117 runs in the 1st inning, Royals starters allowed 103 runs, and Sox starters allowed 96.

Oakland starters allowed just 65 runs.

It's no surprise that John Lackey allowed the most with 26 1st inning runs, but Jon Lester allowed 19 and while Beckett just 13. It could be worse as he gave up a team leading five homers.

4. If the 1st inning is so bad, why is the 2nd inning even worse?
Baltimore allowed 105 1st inning runs and the Sox and Jays allowed 98 each.

Angels pitchers in 162 2nd innings allowed only 51 runs.

In 23 2nd innings, Tim Wakefield allowed 21 runs. Lester gave up 13, but Beckett allowed just seven.

5. How do the Sox get their starters in shape?
There has been a lot of talk about the conditioning of Bostons pitchers. We could clearly see it in a number of them stood on the mound, but here is a way to quantify it. Lets assume that the first 100 pitches thrown in a game belong to the starter. We have already acknowledged that the first two innings have been shaky, which is why opponents hit .247 on the first 25 pitchers of the game. Sox pitchers settled down on the next 25 and held batters to a .235 batting average. They started weakening slightly on pitches 51-75 as the average moved up to .241. But conditioning is a critical part of pitches 76-100 and opponents rattled Sox pitchers for a .278 BAA. That included Clay Buchholz .324, Wakes .333, and Lackeys .348.

Do not blame Beckett, even when he threw over 101 pitches batters only hit .196 from that point on. However, if you want to look at it as the season progressed as opposed to as the game progressed:

In June batters hit .213 against the Sox starters. In July: .292. In August: .257.
In September they hit an even .300. That includes Jon Lesters .282 BAA in six September starts.
6. Where do you bat Carl Crawford?
Carl Crawford had one horrible month (April, when hit .155), one good month (May, when he hit .304) and the rest of the season was just mediocre (June through September, he hit .269). Last September, Crawford hit .360. This season, just .264. There really was nothing encouraging about the season for Crawford. He only had 18 steals and from June on he only had 11 steals in 13 attempts. He was not a threat or a distraction. He is a career .262 hitter against lefties but this year he looked totally out of sync as he hit just .195, down 61 points from 2010. Crawford has batted in every slot in the batting order in his career and this year he only didnt bat clean-up or 9th.

He has made it clear he doesnt like hitting leadoff and he proved it by hitting by hitting .094 in seven starts.

His best spots were seventh and sixth in which he hit .315 and.280 respectively. The only trouble is that he only scored 19 runs from the seventh position, as the batters behind him were the weakest in the Sox lineup.
7. Where do you bat Jacoby Ellsbury?
There is a very good chance that Jacoby Ellsbury could win the AL MVP. He put together one of the great seasons in Red Sox history. He hit .321, scored 119 runs, drove in 105, hit 32 homers and stole 39 bases. The 32 homers moved his career total to 52, but his 39 steals is the fewest of his three complete season (he previously had stole 50 and 70). Thanks to Jacoby:

Red Sox leadoff batters led the AL with a .310 batting average.
Red Sox leadoff batters tied Texas for the AL lead with 33 homers.
Red Sox leadoff batters led the AL with 105 RBI.

Jacoby and Texas Ian Kinsler were the only leadoff batters with over 30 homers. Texas is deeper in power throughout its lineup, so if Jacoby is becoming more of a power hitter will he be more valuable deeper in the Boston line-up?

8. Is team speed an issue?
Fortunately baseball is a very different game today than it s was during the steroid era. We get to see well-pitched games and games decided by a mix of power and speed. The question is whether the Sox can compete properly in this new world order.

Would it shock you if I told that Ellsbury this year was an average base stealer? Jacoby was 39 for 54 in steal attempts, a stolen base percentage of 72 percent. The league averaged 72 percent.

Dustin Pedroia averaged 76 percent and Crawford 75 percent as the team averaged 71 percent.

But team speed is not just about stealing bases; its also about taking the extra base and scoring when given the opportunity.

Ponder this: 350 times this season a runner was on first when a single was hit, 248 times the runner moved no farther than second.

How about this: there were 205 times when the Sox had a runner on second when a single was hit, the runner scored 120 times.

Whoever comes in next needs to address both speed and base running skills.

9. Who do you keep, who do you seek?
The Sox have a number of free agents and a number of important decisions need to be made on the makeup of this squad for next year and the years to come. It is more than just talent that needs to be taken under consideration when putting together a ballclub. Yes, there is the budget, but there is also team composition, an issue that has not seemed like a priority lately. Next years manager and general manager will clearly need to be chemists, but also an alchemist, a person who turns lead into gold.

Starting Monday, Nation STATion will look at the numbers for the Sox free agents, so that you can best decide who keep and who to send packing.

Quotes, notes and stars: Ortiz the oldest to hit 30 home runs in a season


Quotes, notes and stars: Ortiz the oldest to hit 30 home runs in a season

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. -- Quotes, notes and stars from the Red Sox' 4-3 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays:


"It's one of those freak things. You don't plan on it happening, but it's one of those things. So we'll just see what the results say and move on from there.'' - Andrew Benintendi on his knee injury.

"That's kind of a routine 3-1 play. Unfortunately, it comes at a time when you've got two outs and a guy on the move. But that's a routine play.'' - John Farrell on the deciding play in which Heath Hembree couldn't hold onto the ball at first.

"I felt good. I felt strong.I felt good out there the whole game.'' - Rick Porcello, asked how he felt going back out for the eighth inning.

"I think everybody in the ballpark knew that that ball was leaving.'' - Porcello, on the hanging curveball to Evan Longoria.



* The loss snapped a five-game winning streak against the Rays for the Red Sox.

* Three of the four Red Sox walk-off losses this season have occurred because of errors.

* The homer by Evan Longoria was his first off Rick Porcello in 40 career at-bats.

* Rick Porcello has now pitched seven innings or more in six straight starts, the longest run for a Red Sox starter since John Lackey did it in 2013.

* David Ortiz is now the oldest player to ever hit 30 homers in a season

* Ortiz has now reached the 30-homer, 100-RBI level 10 times with the Red Sox, including the last four years in a row.

* The loss was the first of Heath Hembree's career, in his 67th major league appearance.

* Dustin Pedroia tied a career high with two stolen bases, the 12th time he's swiped two bases in the same game.



1) Evan Longoria

The Rays were down to their final five outs when Longoria struck, hitting a game-tying homer off Rick Porcello.

2) Brad Miller

Miller's two-run double in the third enabled the Rays to stay close until Longoria's homer tied things up five innings later.

3) Rick Porcello

Porcello gave the Sox length and was brilliant in getting out of some early jams before settling in through the middle innings.


Shaughnessy: Everything Farrell does blows up in his face, particularly in 8th inning

Shaughnessy: Everything Farrell does blows up in his face, particularly in 8th inning

Dan Shaughnessy joins Sports Tonight to discuss Rick Porcello giving up a game-tying homerun in the 8th, and explains why John Farrell has been very unlucky with any decision he makes.

First impressions: Benintendi injured in Red Sox' 4-3 loss to Rays


First impressions: Benintendi injured in Red Sox' 4-3 loss to Rays

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. -- First impressions from the Red Sox' 4-3 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays:


The injury to Andrew Benintendi looked ominous.

Benintendi's left leg buckled as he tried to elude a tag on the bases in the seventh inning. He left the game with the help of two trainers, hobbling badly.

The Sox later announced that Benintendi suffered a left knee sprain, and will be further evaluated Thursday.

It's impossible to determine how serious the injury is. The prognosis could be anywhere from a few days, to, potentially, a season-ending issue.

Regardless, it's a blow to the Sox, who clearly have benefited from Benintendi's athleticism and energy in the three weeks since he's been promoted from Double A.


Rick Porcello is gobbling up innings in the second half.

Porcello gave the Sox 7 2/3 innings Wednesday night, allowing three runs. It marked the sixth straight start in which Porcello provided the Sox with a minimum of seven innings.

Through the end of June, Porcello had pitched seven or more innings just four times. Since the start of July, he's done it seven times -- and came within an out of doing it in another start.

Porcello also extended his streak of pitching at least five innings to 34 straight starts, dating back almost a calendar year to Aug. 26 of last year. Of those 34, he's pitched at least six in 31 of those.

In fact, Porcello leads the majors in innings pitched since that streak began.


David Ortiz continues to amaze

In the first inning, Ortiz walloped a pitch into the right field seats for his 30th homer, giving the Sox a 2-0 lead three batters into the game.

The homer was significant beyond that, too. With it, Ortiz reached two milestones -- 30 homers and 100 RBI for the season.

It marked the fourth straight season in which Ortiz has reached both, and it also marked the 10th time as a member of the Sox that he had hit both plateaus.

The homer also meant that Ortiz is now the oldest player - at 40 years, 280 days old -- to hit 30 homers in a season. And finally, it gave Ortiz 100 RBI seasons with the Sox, passing Ted Williams, with whom he had shared the record of nine.

And, remarkably, there's more than a month left in the season to add on to those achievements.