NHL, NHLPA still short of the goal


NHL, NHLPA still short of the goal

Lets start with the positives.

The NHL and NHLPA are now on the same wavelength, and the players union admitted it saw a step forward in the leagues alterations to the make-whole provision first discussed last weekend. That means the hawkish NHL owners are now willing to fund some portion of the deferred plan to guarantee full payment on player contracts signed prior to the lockout. Depending on how much of the make-whole pie the owners are willing to fund, it could be a concession in the 200 million-plus range, and that's certainly nothing to sneeze at.

The details are fuzzy on exactly how much the owners are actually willing to pay, and one source said a significant gap still remains." Still, thats normal in negotiations, and may not necessarily prevent an agreement that would have training camps open right after Thanksgiving. The sides are also still both talking and being cordial toward each other, so that's also encouraging.

Now for the negatives.

The NHL hasnt moved much closer to the middle ground on anything else. Sure, the two sides are working off a similar script on some details, but the NHL has basically told the players they must accept the contract rights that have been previously offered. That means there's been no discernible bend or compromise from the league on:

Preventing players from becoming free agents before eight years of service, and before a player reaches the age of 28.

Subtracting one year of arbitration eligibility.

Capping term limits for contracts at five years.

Allowing only five percent variability on each year of a particular contract.

And, perhaps most importantly:

The owners are still demanding an immediate reset to a 5050 split of revenue in the first year of the new CBA. The NHLPA has proposed a staggered three-year lowering of the split until it reaches 5050 in 2014-15. But it appears the owners are holding fast on this point, and it could be their end game in these CBA negotiations.

Its been speculated the NHL will bend a little on some of the contract-rights issues coveted by the players, who hope to keep them as close to the previous CBA as possible. But the NHL hasnt given any indication theres any flexibility at all since their last offer on Oct. 18, and that will be a key talking point over the next segment of negotiations. So far it's been a laborious, slow-moving process where calling it a slow crawl would be engaging in hyperbole.

"We've taken some steps, but there's still a lot more bridges to cross," said one source on the players side of things. "There's still a lot more work to be done."

The NHL and NHLPA are still planning to meet face-to-face on Friday, when, according to one source, they will discuss pension issues along with other assorted CBA talking points that have regularly been on the agenda. It will bring the total amount of time they've spent negotiating this week to about 20 hours, the longest stretch of talks in months.

It's been a deliberate crawl from each side toward the middle ground prompted by the cancelling of the Winter Classic. But watching the relative unwillingness to bend from either side begs the question just what else is going to get cancelled, whacked or flamed into scorched earth before Gary Bettman, Donald Fehr and Co. decide to make a big move in the other sides direction.

A season of 64 games, kicking off on Dec. 1, is still very much a reachable goal. But the clock is ticking and major strides are still needed. Neither side has fully blinked, and one gets the sense we still haven't heard the "final offer" from either the NHL or the NHLPA.

Could the NHL compromise and extend contract-term limits to seven years, or return free agency back to previous level of 27 years old and seven years of service, as an olive branch to the players?

Of course it could.

Could the players decide its not worth protecting entry-level contracts, and roll the dice in that area while making certain to get satisfactory player contract situations elsewhere?

Thats a certainty.

Its nice the league and the players have toned down the rhetoric and finally rolled up their sleeves for good, old-fashioned negotiating. But that also means there must be proper give-and-take in both areas, and there still isnt much give from the NHL aside from the make-whole scenario.

In all fairness, a little less "take" from the players side would also streamline the negotiating process. But this lockout has been more a leagueownercommissioner thing than its been a player thing, and thats widely understood by everyone. It's nice to be cautiously optimistic, but it would also be nicer if the NHL would off some of their other Oct. 18 "concessions."

The NHL needs to do much better with the stench of the cancelled Winter Classic still fresh in the winter air, and the players need to keep pushing their leadership to make a deal thats in the best interest of both the game and the players. Both sides are slowly, surely closing in on the makings of a workable deal, but neither side should be ecstatic with the final CBA document that clears up the lockout haze.

Thats the true sign of a fair deal for both sides, and theyre not at all close to one of those just yet in an excruciating process for hockey fans.

Royer's late goal rallies Red Bulls past Revolution, 2-1


Royer's late goal rallies Red Bulls past Revolution, 2-1

HARRISON, N.J. - Daniel Royer finished a nice sequence in the 74th minute, Luis Robles made a diving save in the closing minutes and the New York Red Bulls rallied to beat the New England Revolution 2-1 on Saturday night.

Felipe sent the ball left to Kemar Lawrence alongside the box and he put a cross to Royer on the back post for an easy finish on his fourth goal.

Robles, who only allowed Lee Nguyen's penalty kick in the ninth minute, preserved the win with his fourth save, diving to his left to block Diego Fagundez's shot from outside the box.

Bradley Wright-Phillips tied it for New York (6-6-2), which was winless in its last four matches, when he pounced on a loose ball and backheeled it into the net. New England goalkeeper Cody Cropper had pounced on a cross by Kemar Lawance, but Cropper could hold on and Wright-Phillips was there to clean up for his sixth goal.

Damien Perrinelle fouled Fagundez in the penalty area after a great pass from Kei Kamara, allowing Nguyen to step up for his sixth goal. New England (4-5-4) had won two straight and lost just one of its previous six. It is 0-5-2 on the road.