Boston Red Sox

Nation STATion: Looking back, looking forward


Nation STATion: Looking back, looking forward

This is the last regularly scheduled Nation STATion of the season; that is not to say you have read the last of me, but it is the end of my twice-weekly contributions to Today, I am emptying out the Bill Chuck Files as I provide some closing thoughts.

The Sox have seven free agents:
Conor Jackson, OF-1B While I like players who can play multiple positions, and Jackson can do that, you want someone who does more than fill a roster slot. Over the last three seasons, Jackson, playing for Arizona, Oakland, and Boston, has had 741 plate appearances with a .232 avg. and eight homers. Jackson is not worth bringing back.

Erik Bedard, LHP Bedard would have been the Game 3 starter in the ALDS had the Sox made it that far. Dont let that designation fool you; the Sox simply had no one else. Ironically, that might be the case again next season for the number four slot in the rotation. If the Sox let him go, Bedard has all the potential for being a guy referred to by Bob Lobel as why cant we get pitchers like that? On the other hand, he also has the potential to be the guy who joins Dice-K and Lackey as out for the season. Bedard lost all of the 2010 season and since 2008 he has started just 54 games and gone 16-16 with a 3.41 ERA and a 1.268 ERA.

Tim Wakefield, RHP If you are not part of the solution, you are part of the problem. While I respect Tim Wakefield on so many different levels, I do think because he didnt exert leadership last season that he was part of the problem. I cared that he sought 200 wins only because I didnt think it would be fair that he ended his career at 199 wins, but after that significant moment, I hoped that he would never make another appearance. The reality is this: over the last five seasons, Wake is 49-46 with a 4.76 ERA and a 1.328 WHIP. Since 2007, the only Sox pitcher with at least 50 appearances and worse ERA and WHIP numbers than Wakefield is John Lackey. Case closed.

J.D. Drew, RF Theo defended his Drew signing (repeatedly) by stating that in 2008 and 2009 he had an OPS over .900 each season. His .920 OPS was even better than Adrian Gonzalez .913. In fact, it was 13th best in the majors. But in the 220 games he played from 2010-2011, Drew had a .733 OPS, good for 124th in the majors, although it was still better than Derek Jeter (.725) and Jimmy Rollins (.720). Consider that last reference as my going away present to Day-to Day Drew.

Jason Varitek, C If I told you that the Sox are signing a free agent who, over the last four seasons, had hit .218 and had a .308 OBP, how excited would you be? What if I told you that the guy would be 40 as we started the season? The person described is Jason Varitek and its time to say so long. He provided no leadership this past year as Captain, he allowed 73 of 85 runners to steal off of him, and Josh Beckett does not deserve a personal receiver. Thanks for everything, Tek.

David Ortiz, DH Big Papi had a very good and surprising season. He hit .309, had a .398 OBP, and slugged .554. He hit 29 homers and drove home 96. So why do I not support signing him beyond a year or two? To start with, he will be 36 in a few weeks. No player 36 or older this season hit more homers than the 20 by 39-year old Raul Ibanez, who also drove home 84 runs to lead the senior circuit (not to be confused with the National League, just those over 36). Secondly, Papi gives you no flexibility, as he is a defensive non-entity. Thirdly, Ortiz is seeking a three-year deal. The Sox should not be thinking beyond a year and an option. Fourthly, putting age aside, with lefties Crawford and Gonzalez already locked in, the Sox have to look to become more right-handed. Look for the Sox to offer arbitration and then well see what happens. The Sox dont need a dedicated DH.

Jonathan Papelbon, Closer The Sox do need pitching. They need starters, they need relievers, and if Papelbon goes they will need a closer as well. Red Sox Nation seemed to be preparing to say farewell to Papelbon for years, but now at the critical moment, there is no reason not to make at least a three-year offer to keep the closer. Over the last three seasons, Papelbon has secured 106 saves, the fifth highest total. Heath Bell, who is also a free agent, led all relievers with 132. Bell had too big a personality for Theo, but Cherington could add a good guy and a good closer if Papelbon leaves.

Dual option
Marco Scutaro, SS Put it in the books; the first transaction of the Ben Cherington era was picking up Marco Scutaros option. At 6 million this was almost a no-brainer. Scutaro hit .299 and didnt quit. The Sox need another year to see if Jose Iglesias makes some progress at the plate at Pawtucket or if he is hyped trade bait for a pitcher. Jed Lowrie is injured too frequently, but that doesnt make him a bad backup. It just makes him someone you cant count on to be a starter. He, too, could be traded. Figure Scutaro to be the 2012 shortstop UNLESS the Sox decide to give a Carl Crawford-sized contract to Jose Reyes. The switch-hitting Reyes led the NL in batting, hitting .337, and led in triples with 16. Hes stolen 98 bases over the past two seasons despite playing just 259 games. His durability is one of his problems; the other is his -4 defense. Jimmy Rollins is another option, but he feels old. Rafael Furcal is also available but you get the sense the Sox have had shortstops like him already. If the Sox do sign another name shortstop, Scutaro will either be traded or be the utility guy as Lowrie is traded.

Club option
Dan Wheeler, righty in the pen Wheeler had a disappointing season with a 4.38 ERA, but the Sox could grab him again for 3 million. He had three good seasons with the Rays from 2008-10 with a 3.19 in his last two seasons. In 28 games in June, July, and August he held batters to a .176 batting average. I would bring back the veteran.

Andrew Miller, lefty starter Im not a Miller man, but I still think that at 1.6 million, you have to bring him back and keep trying to make it work. Hell be 27 in May and while he has never had an ERA under 4.84, hes the kind of guy the Sox need to take chances on.

Arbitration Eligible
Jacoby Ellsbury, OF Jacoby wont be a free agent until 2014. He made 2.4 million last year and will make plenty in arbitration next season. Hes 28 and he will be coming into his prime. You already know how good his numbers were and if Im Cherington Im throwing money at Jacoby Ellsbury. Tell him you love him and tell him that you want him here long-term. Tell him. Tell him, right now. Call his agent Scott Boras, make an offer and see if you could lock up him up for the next six or seven years. That would make a big statement on the direction of this team.

Daniel Bard, bullpen Bard hasnt been a starter since his first professional season in 2007 when he made 22 starts and had a 7.08 ERA in the minors, but I wouldnt mind seeing him and Alfredo Aceves battling for a rotation slot in spring training. The new pitching coach should make Bard his project.
Alfredo Aceves, RHP You cant say enough about Aceves performance in 2012. If he stays healthy, he should continue to be outstanding in whatever role the Sox use him. Health has been an issue in the past.

Matt Albers, RHP In July, Albers held batters to a .163 batting average; in August he was hit at a .346 rate. There are a lot of relievers floating around: Ryan Madson, Joe Nathan, Brad Lidge, Francisco Rodriguez, Matt Capps, Frank Francisco, and Jonathan Broxton, to name a few. I would non-tender Albers and take my chances shopping.

Rich Hill, LHP He will be the first of three Sox pitchers recovering from Tommy John. He wont be back until the All-Star break, but at 31 he may have some good pitches left. Even so, I would non-tender him; after all, hes only pitched 12 innings the last two seasons.

Scott Atchison, RHP Atchison always seemed to be the last guy Tito would go to, but when called upon Atchison had a 3.26 ERA and a 1.220 WHIP. Batters did hit .279 against him, however. Atchison is a cheap date and worthy of returning.

Franklin Morales, LHP Morales made 424,000 last year and had a so-so year, so he wont cost them a lot to retain and the Sox should do that. He held lefties to a .238 batting average and righties to a .235. He doesnt like pitching at Fenway, however. His ERA on the road was 1.27, but at home it was 5.76.

Jarrod Saltalamacchia, C Jarrod put a lot minds at ease with the way he performed last season. But he still hit just .235 and while he showed power with 16 homers, he does strike out once every 3 at bats. Defensively, his pitchers had a 4.63 ERA, but he did throw out 31 of the runners attempting steals. Next year, he will be pushed by Ryan Lavarnway who may split time as backup catcher and DH.

Jed Lowrie, SS-3B Lowrie hit .368 the first month of the season, but hit .220 with a .280 OBP the rest of the way and continued to struggle to stay healthy. The Sox will pick up his option, but he is trade-bait, even if he is the closest friend (read only) of Jacoby Ellsbury on the team.

Mike Aviles, INF I would much rather see Aviles as the utility guy than Lowrie, only because I know hell be healthy. Aviles gives you a fair bat (.255), but not that much defense. I wouldnt be surprised if hes non-tendered and then maybe re-signed.

Darnell McDonald, OF McDonald finished at .236 because he hit .382 in September; he really hit very little to that point of the season (.195). He only hit .260 against lefties and that wasnt enough. I suspect that McDonald will be non-tendered.

Guaranteed contracts
Adrian Gonzalez, 1B Gonzo at 29 is signed for 154 million through 2018. He had a great season in 2011, but it wasnt great enough. He hit .354 before the break and .317 after it. He drove home 31 runs in May, but just 27 in August and September combined. Another year removed from shoulder surgery should help him, but the question is whether he can shoulder the leadership that this team needs.

Carl Crawford, OF Crawford is owed 128 million through 2017 and needs some good things to happen pretty soon into the 2012 season. He pretty much got a mulligan for the 2011 season, but that wont carry over the offseason. Moving him to second in the lineup might help Crawford but there are so many lefties there already.

Dustin Pedroia, 2B Pedey is owed 29.25 million through 2014 and is a bargain at twice the price. And channeling Forrest Gump, thats all I have to say about him.

Kevin Youkilis, 3B Youk is signed for next season for 12 million and the club has a 13 million option for 2013. You get the feeling the love affair between the two is nearing its end. After three straight seasons of at least a .958 OPS, it was .833 last year. His batting average dropped 49 points. He hasnt played over 136 games in three years. The question of whether Youk will be traded is valid but I think it is more dependent on what the market will bear as opposed to any real desire to keep him. His cranky attitude doesnt seem to be appreciated, but he is a right-hand bat and thats what the Sox still need.

Josh Reddick, RF Reddick was hitting .414 on July 9, but he hit .240 the rest of the way. He looked overmatched most of the second half of the season and he, too, is a left-hand hitter. Hopefully Ryan Kalish will be healthy this coming spring and he and Reddick will both try to make this big league club or some other if either is traded.

John Lackey, SP The good news is he wont be back in 2012. The bad news is he probably will be in 2013.

Daisuke Matsuzaka, SP The good news is he wont be back early in 2012. The bad news is he probably will be in late 2012. His contract expires at the end of this season.

Jon Lester, SP This coming season is critical for Lester. He came into the 2011 season as the expected winner of the Cy Young Award and fell far short. He had a 3.47 ERA and a 1.257 WHIP, neither CYA worthy. His relationship with Josh Beckett was not a good call. Jon Lester needs to grow up on and off the field if he wants to fulfill his potential and win the Cy Young and, more importantly, be a ture ace of this staff.

Clay Buchholz, SP The Red Sox on June 21 defeated the Rays in Tampa, 4-2. Clay Buchholz was the winning pitcher. Their record on that date was 41-27 .603. Their record from that date forward was 49-45 .521. June 21 was the last appearance of Clay Buchholz and Theo never really replaced him. Buchholz is signed through 2015 plus 2016-17 club options. The Sox need his back to be healthy. They need Buch back.

Bobby Jenks, RHP Jenks is signed for another year at 6 million. Theo-retically, Epstein thought this was a good deal. So far, not good. He was a physical mess last year but he also didnt pitch well in his last two seasons with the White Sox with a 4.08 ERA and a 1.321 WHIP. They cant get anything in return for him, so heres hoping hell have a great contract year.

Josh Beckett, SP Beckett is making 15.75 a season for each of the next three years. He got his contract extension because Epstein signed Lackey for 15.25 for the next three years. Fact: He was the Sox' best pitcher last season. Fact: He totally let the team down in AugustSeptember and brought others down with him. In his last 10 starts he was 6-4 with a 4.50 ERA as he ate and drank himself out of shape. If I were in on the interviews for a new manager, the question I would ask would be, How are you going to deal with Josh Beckett?

Free agents
Hopefully, the Sox wont bid on Yu Darvish. While this kid may actually be good, he probably is a 3 or 4 starter and we have seen how ugly it can be when you aim that low. Plus, he wont get a break following the disaster known as Dice-K.

C.J. Wilson is way more intriguing to me than Edwin Jackson. Jackson has great stuff, but he needs it because he is constantly putting runners on base. Over the last four seasons, with time spent in Tampa Bay, Detroit, White Sox town, and St. Louis, Jackson has a 4.09 ERA and a WHIP of 1.395. Wilson has been a starter for two seasons now and is 31-15 with a 3.14 ERA, a 1.215 WHIP and 376 strikeouts in 427.1 innings.

The Sox should be involved in the rumors for every starter who is made available for trade, including Fausto Carmona and Jonathan Sanchez. I wonder what it would take to pry Matt Cain from the Giants.

Speaking of the Giants, Carlos Beltran, the switch-hitting outfielder, ended his season playing out in San Francisco and the oft-injured free-agent will get lots of interest from the Sox, Yankees (although they just re-signed Nick Swisher), and other clubs, including the Giants. Beltran hit .300 with 22 home runs and 84 RBI in 142 games. He played in a combined 145 games in 2009 and 2010. Beltran turns 35 in April.

Michael Cuddyer is another interesting possibility for right field (he also has played first and third). He will be 33 for the 2012 season and is a right-handed hitter who has averaged .276, 22 homers and 82 RBI over the last three seasons.

Jason Kubel is another Twins free agent outfielder, but hits from the left side. He was hurt last season, which drives down his price and ups his risk. Hes a lifetime .271 hitter and is good for 20 homers in a healthy season.

David DeJesus is a left-handed hitting outfielder who had a big drop of 78 points in his batting average last season, so he is not that appealing.

Grady Sizemore was once a star in the field; now he is a star on the operating table just having undergone his fifth surgery. While I know there is a spot open on the DL with the departure of Drew, my hope is that Grady plays a year elsewhere, shows some good health, and the Sox can overpay him in the future.

And, in conclusion
Thank you to the folks (Sean, Art and Phil) at Comcast SportsNet New England who were so accommodating to me in this first season at Nation STATion. A special thank you to all for your kind comments and recommendations. Im a big fan of my readers.

Please join me throughout the dark months as I will be writing on this offseason and for Nick Cafardo every Sunday in the Boston Globe and you never know when you might find me again in this space.

Looking forward to seeing you and hearing from you soon.

Drellich: Red Sox role-d once again by Farrell's bullpen usage

Drellich: Red Sox role-d once again by Farrell's bullpen usage

CLEVELAND -- John Farrell is fighting himself. More than he might realize, he’s willing to mix up his bullpen usage in a way that’s smart. But in some of the most crucial innings, Farrell will stubbornly and perhaps reflexively revert to tradition and a false sense of role -- one that actually runs counter to the logic the manager employs at other times.

Look at the big cat, Craig Kimbrel, who was again left in the bullpen Monday night as the eighth and ninth innings deteriorated in a 5-4 Red Sox loss to the Indians. 


It’s all about the inning with Kimbrel, you see -- or in Monday’s case, it's a matter of when Farrell would have been forced to use him.

“[If] I use Kimbrel tonight, [he'll] need . . . one, if not two days off,” Farrell said. “That's why you need the contributions from everyone.”

But the indication was Kimbrel was available for a save, or perhaps the 10th inning when the lineup turned over again. If he needs rest, rest him. Farrell did not say that Kimbrel was down entirely.

But the eighth inning? No, that’d be lunacy.

“I know that there’s this overriding thought that you can just drop Craig Kimbrel in anywhere from the sixth inning to the ninth inning,” Farrell said Friday. “And with all due respect, there’s a lot more that goes into it than just that. We’ve used Craig for four outs or more this year. And there’s a willingness to do that. 

“But when we’re completely rested down there, there are roles [in which] guys have performed very well . . . And there’s a reason why our bullpen has excelled to the point they have. There are roles that are established and they pitch to them.”

Seriously, what roles? The roles change as often as Farrell’s logic defending them, aside from Kimbrel’s overwhelming need to be in save situations.

The Sox were not “completely rested” on Monday, for one. Addison Reed was unavailable entirely.

But step back for a moment, and look at the overall usage of the reliever who initially got the Red Sox into trouble Monday in the eighth, Matt Barnes. 

The righty this year has pitched in the sixth inning three times. He’s been used in the seventh inning 18 times and the eighth inning 29 times, including Monday. 

Another nine times, Barnes has pitched in the ninth or later. Fourteen times, he’s made multi-inning appearances.

Does that sound like a rigid role to you?

When Farrell spoke recently of his plan for using Reed and Barnes, it sounded pretty darn progressive.

"Addision, we’ve initially said it’s the eighth inning," Farrell said. "We’ve used him accordingly based on where we are in the lineup and based on the potential of running threats . . . As we map out the seventh and eighth inning, it’s going to be Barnes and Addison and we’ll see where the right matchups provide themselves.”

So what matters more, lineup position and running threats, or what inning it is?

Depends which reliever Farrell is talking about on which night, or maybe which way the wind is blowing.

For Monday night, Barnes all of a sudden was a reliever with a role.

“On a night when not everyone's available, [Barnes is] the one that has had the most experience in the eighth inning against both lefties and righties,” Farrell said.

Experience in a particular inning, now that’s the primary factor for Barnes? What about the fact Barnes has been terrible on the road lately?

What about the fact that Brandon Workman has a 1.40 ERA, or that Farrell said before the game Workman is now in the high-leverage mix?

Workman gave up a leadoff double on Monday in the ninth inning. He might have blown the eighth inning anyway. Farrell also prefers a clean inning for Workman, and wanted to avoid using the righty Monday for workload reasons as well.

But Workman was, indeed, available. So why let extra innings or a tie game in the ninth force you to use him, as opposed to pitching him at a time he perhaps could have protected the lead?

Workman in the eighth could have thrown in place of either Barnes or Heath Hembree. The latter’s done worse than anyone on the Sox with inherited runners and came on to try to clean up Barnes’ mess. Workman has six inherited runners this year and none have scored.

But Workman has a role. Except he doesn’t. Or if he does, it’s as loosely defined as everybody else’s, save for the guy who can only get saves.


Guyer scores winner on Holt's error in 9th, Indians top Red Sox, 5-4


Guyer scores winner on Holt's error in 9th, Indians top Red Sox, 5-4

CLEVELAND -- Andrew Miller wasn't among the Cleveland Indians chasing Roberto Perez around the infield, flinging water and white powder to celebrate a wild win over an American League rival.

The Indians relief ace - a pivotal piece during Cleveland's run to the World Series last season - may miss a few more big moments this season, too.

Miller's injury put a damper on a 5-4 walk-off victory Monday night over the Boston Red Sox, a game that ended when first baseman Brock Holt threw away Perez's bunt in the ninth inning, allowing Brandon Guyer to score from second base.

Miller left in the seventh after aggravating the patellar tendinitis in his right knee. Miller spent over two weeks on the disabled list with the injury before returning Friday. This was his second appearance since.

Manager Terry Francona said Miller will be evaluated Tuesday, but it seems likely that he'll return to the DL.

"Hope for the best and hope that it's not a big deal," Miller said. "It stinks missing any time. I've already missed 12 days or something like that. I don't want to do it again. We'll find out more (Tuesday). See how I wake up."

"That's not what we were hoping for, but we'll let the medical people put their heads together and see what they can do," Francona said.

Miller began the seventh by walking Red Sox star Mookie Betts on six pitches - including a number of fastballs that failed to reach 90 mph - and then threw one pitch to Andrew Benintendi before walking off the mound. Francona and a team trainer had a brief conversation with Miller, who then left the field.

Miller said he was optimistic that he had turned the corner with the injury, but that changed when he entered the game.

"It was kind of not really crisp the first pitches," he said. "But the pitch I pulled inside to Mookie, I kind of felt it. And I threw one more and it was the same thing."

The left-hander is 4-3 with a 1.65 ERA and has 79 strikeouts in 54 2/3 innings.

After Guyer's leadoff double against Brandon Workman (0-1) in the ninth, Holt fielded the bunted ball and tried to throw out Guyer at third. Guyer slid into the bag as the throw skipped past third baseman Rafael Devers, then got to his feet and raced across home plate.

"It was just a routine play," Holt said. "I couldn't get it out of the glove, fumbled it a little bit, and then tried to rush the throw, and made a bad one."

Holt replaced Mitch Moreland, who was a late scratch because of a sore neck. Moreland took a forearm in the back of the head from Holt on a play Sunday. Manager John Farrell said Moreland passed concussion tests, but he decided to hold him out of the lineup.

Perez also had a three-run homer in the second inning.

Cody Allen (1-6) allowed Christian Vazquez's leadoff single in the ninth, but retired the next three hitters. The inning ended when shortstop Francisco Lindor ran down Betts' popup in center field with his back to home plate.

Boston led 4-3 behind two-run homers by Hanley Ramirez and Andrew Benintendi before Edwin Encarnacion tied the game in the eighth with an RBI single.

Eduardo Rodriguez allowed three runs in 5 2/3 innings for Boston. Mike Clevinger allowed both homers and gave up four runs in 4 1/3 innings for Cleveland.

Jay Bruce was 1 for 4 in his first home game since being acquired from the New York Mets on Aug. 9.


Plate umpire Hunter Wendelstedt was struck on the mask by a warmup pitch in the sixth inning from Red Sox reliever Joe Kelly. Wendelstedt finished the inning, but left while Miller was warming up, which led to a 10-minute delay as second base umpire Alan Porter changed his gear.

Indians first baseman Carlos Santana also left the game with an injury, exiting in the eighth inning with lower back tightness.


Red Sox: LHP Drew Pomeranz (back spasms) says he's on schedule to start Wednesday after a bullpen session Monday. He left his start against the Yankees on Friday in the fourth inning. "I feel pretty good," he said. "The progression is a little better every day, so I'm looking to keep getting that improvement."

Indians: OF Michael Brantley (sprained right ankle) is hitting and playing catch but hasn't started running. He's on the disabled list for the second time this season with the injury.


RHP Doug Fister will face Cleveland for the third time in his last four starts Tuesday. He defeated the Indians on July 31, allowing two runs in 7 2/3 innings, but gave up five runs in 4 1/3 innings and got the loss Aug. 14. RHP Carlos Carrasco didn't make it out of the second inning against Boston on Aug. 2, allowing five runs.