Earlier today Red Sox insider Sean McAdam took some time to field questions from Red Sox Nation. Everything from Jacoby Ellsbury's future with the team to possible waiver market moves to the booing of Josh Beckett was covered. Take a look at the full transcript below:
Live Chat Moderator:
Hey everyone, thanks for joining us for our live chat with Red Sox insider Sean McAdam. Sean will be joining us shortly but feel free to send your questions in now!
Hi folks, and thanks for joining the chat. Let's get to the questions, shall we?
Comment From Josh
Is there any way the sox resign Jacoby Ellsbury? Jackie Bradley Jr is in the mold of Carl Crawford in every aspect. There are teams that would take a lot of CC contract, Sox could sign Ellsbury for cheaper. He is obviously the better player. Thoughts?
To get Ellsbury extended, the Sox will have to overpay this winter because that's how things work with Scott Boras' clients: he wants his guys to reach free agenncy, to enhance their bargaining power. To prevent that from happening, a premium will have to be paid. And remember this, Boras has alluded to Matt Kemp's eight year, 160 million deal with the Dodgers as the starting point. So, no, I don't see him being re-signed.
Comment From matt from boston
sean, what was the red sox reaction to beckett being booed after leaving the game with an injury. players, coaches, etc.
Didn't talk to a lot of players about it, but Valentine addressed and said, essentially, that when fans realize today that Beckett was indeed injured, they would regret booing him.
Comment From Adam
Any reports as to who the Sox would have rcvd from Texas in that deal?
I saw that there was a report of a "blockbuster'' involving Beckett, Ellsbury and Shppach.'' I thinlk these sort of bigger deals get discussed a lot, with a lot of names going back and forth in various proposals. I don't know who would have been coming back, but I'm guessting that it would have been premium prospects. Texas has two great infield prospects -- 3B Mike Olt and SS Jurickson Profar, but they've been comnsidered pretty much untouchable.
Comment From Wally from Yawkey Way
Is this 4 game winning streak legit or is this team pulling another fast one on us? I can't take the unrest anymore!!!!
Good question, Wally. They've been getting better starting pitching during the run, so that's helped. And it's come against two good teams, so that's encouraging, too. Time will tell. The Sox have insisted that they have a good run in them; let's see if this is the start of it.
Comment From Mike
Nice article on the revamping of the bullpen (again!). 2 Questions: 1. You didn't mention Melancon in your article? Where does he stand and what have we seen from him so far? 2. Will Morales take a turn in the rotation with Beckett dealing with back injuries?
Thanks, Mike. I thought Melancon was gaining Valentine's trust, but he's had a couple of rough outings of late and I see him more as a guy they'll only use when they're behind -- at least for now. As for Morales, he could step in and take Beckett's spot if Beckett has to go on the DL, or he could be used to spot-start, especially against the Yankees.
Comment From matt from boston
sean, let's assume the red sox have a great homestand go like 8-2, 7-3 whatever. will the sox actully consider trying to pick up a starting pitcher through waivers, knowing that it may not fall in their lap. and by the way, if bobby v is waiting for regret from the fans, don't hold your breath.
If they have a good next 10 days, I can see them stepping up their search for a starter, even if it's only a rental. Remember, it's more likely that pitchers with lots of money due them will get through waivers, since teams will be less likely to block those guys out of fear of being stuck with them. Re: the booing. I get it. People are frustrated with Beckett, and though he certainly didn't TRY to get injured, the timing last night couldn't have been worse.
Comment From Walter J fernandez
Sean, what was the idea in trading Lars Anderson for a 27 year old AA pitcher? Anderson will not be Anthony Rizzo, but he can bring some value to the Indians. Good OBP guy, why couldn't they have packaged him with someone to help the major league club as they attempted last year.
I'm not sure that Anderson has much value at this point. He's going to be 25 next month and hasn't shown that he can hit major league pitching. Nor has he shown much power at Triple A. That's a tough profile for a 1BLFDH. I think they moved him as a favor and tried to get someone who could surprise and give them something in return.
Comment From Tim
Can you explain the waiver process? When can a player be put on waivers? How long do teams have to claim him? What RS will be placed on waivers and when?
Tim, the waiver process is incredibly complicated, but I'll try to offer the Cliff Notes version. Teams routinely put mostmany of their players through waivers in August, to give them the flexibility of making late summer deals. It's a common practice to put a bunch at the same time through. Once a player clears, even if it's early in August, he can be dealt at any time, even weeks later. If a player is claimed, the original team has the option of granting the claim -- i.e. allowing the player to go --, pulling him back (to determine interest for deals in the off-season, or try to work out a trade with the claiming team. Teams can claim in reverse order of the standings, within the league. So a player in the A.L. would first be available to MINN or SEA, then the team with the next worst record, and so on. Then, if they clear the A.L. teams, the same process is re-started with NL teams.
Hope that helps
Comment From Dillon, Lowell Mass
Why is Shoppach labeled as valuable? I have not seen much out of him and would rather have Larvarnway back up Salty.
1) He's a good receiver and throws well. 2) He crushes LH pitching. He's not considered an every-day catcher, but with his experience, he certainly has value. I'm surprised the Sox held onto him because it certainly seems like they could get by with combination of Saltalamacchia and Lavarnway. He could still be dealt this month, I suppose.
Comment From Michael Corleone - NYNev
Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in (w 4 straight Ws)! Do you think the Sox will make Ellsbury an offer he can't refuse? If not do they trade him before letting him get to free agency? Is he an "A" free agent that would net the Sox some nice prospects from the team that signs him?
I believe the Red Sox will make sort of attempt to extend him this winter and I expect Boras to reject it. At that point, I think they'll attempt to trade him this winter. If he's dealt before the start of next season, the team that gets him can recoup a draft pick if he signs elsewhere. As for the Type A system, that's gone. Now, teams have to present "qualifying offers'' of at least 12 million to recoup picks. But as I said, I don't think it will get to that with the Sox. I expect they deal him this winter.
Comment From Doug from Woburn
Sean, What If the Sox and Crawford can't agree on a course action for his elbow, If CC gets the surgery done without team approval, What then?
That almost never happens. Usually, player, agent and team come to an agreement on how to handle an injury. But it certainly bears watching. I think if the Sox drop out of contention in the next few weeks, it's more likely he'll get the surgery done before the end of the season. If they're in it, he'll play it out and see how he is at the end of the year.
Comment From RI Tony
Would Bobby Valentine make for a better general manager as opposed to an on-field, in the clubhouse manager? I think his talent evaluation is exemplary, but his communication skills are seriously lacking.
In some ways, that's a great point. Valentine has done well with his evaluations. He didn't like the idea of Bard in the rotation and he saw Morales as a good starting candidate. But the role of GM is more complicated than ever, with all the organizational duties of overseeing a farm system, negotiating contracts, handling arbitration, etc. And at 62, Valenitne hasn't done any of those things.
Comment From Bill in North Carolina
You think part of the booing last night was frustration at the front office and their lack of action yesterday?
I suppose it could be interpreted that way, yes. Clearly, a lot of the fans have had it with Beckett and his underperformance since last Sept. as well as some of the issues off-field. I think a lot of fans thought: "OK. he's here. Let's see how he does matched against Verlander and a good team.'' And when he walked off in the third inning, they had reached their limit.
Comment From Brian
If Sweeney doesn't break his hand, is he in Arizona instead of Podsednik?
Hard to say. I think Cincinnati had the most interest in him and I think the Sox would have put him in a different deal, by himself, to get a mid-level prospect back. But I suppose it's possible.
Comment From Vote for Pedro
Any chance Ciriaco gets a chance at a starting role and Aviles moves into a utility job? Sox should play the hot hand (Pedro), no?
I would caution against going overboard on Ciriaco. He's had a nice stretch the last few weeks, but usually, guys like this tend to get exposed over time. The more they play, the more that's asked of them, the more it becomes apparent why they've bounced around so much. But I'll say this: with his speed and versatility, he's shown he's a capable major league role player for some teams.
Comment From Jon
What do you expect from Middlebrooks going forward? Will he be a 30 hr guy next year?
You would expect something like that. He's got 13 homers in about half a season, so that wouldn't be much of a stretch.
Comment From Adam from PEI Canada
Would Boston be wise to approach Arizona this offseason with a package headlined by Ellsbury in an attempt to land Upton (assuming they can convince him to waive the no trade)
The only way Arizona would do that would be to get Ellsbury extended first. Why give up a five-tool player who's 24 and signed for several more seasons for a similar player who can be a FA after 2013? But Ellsbury lives in ARI in the off-season and might be open to staying there.
Comment From Matt in Taunton, MA
Hi Sean. I'm wondering if you have any information on Beckett's injury.
Nothing yet, Matt. Usually, we find about those things when the clubhouse opens the following day. Not sure if the tests are complete. Beckett didn't seem to think it was anything serious and they caught it early before it had the chance to get worse. But worst-case scenario: he slipped on a wet mound at Yankee Stadium in 2010 and missed a third of the season.
Comment From Joekur9
Do you see any correlation between Sox' current winning streak and Tito's impromptu player meeting?
You're the second person to ask me that today! And no, I don't. I don't think it was anything more than Tito catching up with some players he enjoyed managing.
Comment From Brian
Sean, I'm curious how you guys handle the trade deadline. How do you and people like Jon Heyman with CBS get the "inside" information. Your coverage was awesome yesterday, loved you on Felger and Mazz.
Thanks for the kind words, Brian. At deadline time, you talk to sources around the game -- could be scouts, could be an agent, could be someone in a front office somewhere -- and do your best to assemble the most information, while separating fact and fiction.
Comment From Projo-Warren
is trading deadline day one of the hardest for a beat writer ?
It's nerve-wracking, Warren. And the 24-hour news cycle has made it even more demanding. With Twitter, etc., everything is immediate. It used to be that you could take your time throughout the day and build up your information for a story in the next day's paper. Not now, of course -- there are demands to relay the info you have NOW. And, of course, get it right.
Comment From Doug Mcrey, Charlestown
what is your starting lineup for 2013?
Doug, if I could do that, I'd be in Vegas right now, putting my power of forecasting to better use. Way too much stuff could happen between now and then. But as I've said, I'd be surprised if Ellsbury is here next year. And it wouldn't surprise me if there is more turnover, especially if they fail to make the playoffs.
Comment From Warren in Providence
Sean, I am still hoping to hear some specifics as to why the media continually harps on Beckett and Lackey being negative influences on the other pitchers...is this true and if so, what specifically are they doing?
A lot stems from their role in the chicken-and-beer thing last September. Remember, too, that Beckett got out of shape, didn't do some conditioning work last year and that sets a poor example for the younger pitchers. When a staff leader works hard, it sends one message; when he slacks off, it sends an entirely different one. And Beckett is a notoriously stubborn guy who doesn't always take suggestions well, another bad example to set.
Comment From T
Do you think Papi is here next year? Will the Sox "qualify" him (netting a pick if he leaves) by offering the 12M? Thanks
I think he'll return, yes. He's pretty obsessed with getting a multi-year deal, but his leverage isn't the greatest, being an older DH. And yes, they'll certainly make the qualifying offer -- no risk for the club there.
Lots of people standing by -- let's go another 15 minutes or so
Comment From tom
anyway josh hamilton might have been involved in that texas blockbuster with boston?
Highly doubt it. He's a free agent this fall and they wouldn't be giving up a CF whom they control for another year for one who could walk in three months.
Comment From Jon in Phoenix
Any chance of a MastersonKalish swap during the offseason? I think Masterson would slot in well as a 3-4th starter with this team. Also, Doubront seems to have exceeded everyones expectations for his ceiling. Can he be a consistent 4 starter and win 12-13 games as a cost controlled starter?
That deal might make some sense for both teams. Cleveland would get a young OF whom they could control for another 5 years and the Sox get an experienced, versatile pitcher. Though the Sox like Kalish and see him as part of the club going forward, worth thinking about for both sides. Good suggestion! As for Doubront, the Sox have always thought highly of him, but yes, I think it's fair to say he's exceeded expectations for his first full year. And if he harnesses his control and becomes more efficient, he could still improve.
Comment From DilyPickle
Sean, big fan keep up the great work. Do you think Bard will be a valuable piece to the bullpen if the Sox make the playoffs. You can't teach 100mph but he has to locate it.
Could be. He certainly has the talent, as you point out. It's all about throwing strikes, since his stuff can be filthy. As I wrote this morning, he's been better over the last five outings in Pawtucket, walking just two in the last five. So there's hope.
Comment From David
Sean, is Bobby V here next year? Jeff Passan of Yahoo was on EEI the other day and he seemed to believe that was practically a foregone conclusion that he'd be gone.
At this point, I think it's all about how they finish. I believe they have to get into the post-season for Valentine to return. If they miss out, it's a tough sell to the fan base to bring him back after missing the playoffs for three years in a row. And he's already a tough sell in that clubhouse.
Comment From Indiana Mike
Do you see Brad Mills coming back to Boston in some capacity after he gets fired in Houston, either as Bobby V's replacement or on staff? He would seem a fallback if John Farrell is unavailable.
Unlikely. I like Brad a lot and think he's a good teacher. He hasn't had much success in Houston and that will hurt him, even if people recognize that they traded away his best players. Francona didn't win in four years in PHI, so there's always a chance a guy learns a lot and wins with his next team, especially if that second team has talent. Just don't see it happening here for Mills.
Comment From Chris
Who are some of the starting pitchers in next year's free agent class?
Tim Linceum, Matt Garza, Josh Johnson and Chris Carpenter are probably the top four. Some others have options, like Dan Haren and Ervin Santana.
Comment From Sam the Ram
When is someone going to tell Dustin Pedroia that he is not a home run hitter? He is a joke in the clutch and seldom goes for the single when that is all the team needs at the time. Does he avoid criticism because he is a favorite of the writers? Youk played just as hard as Pedroia and he was shipped out of town thanks to the media? Pedroia has been no more productive than Youk.
Hmm, where to start there. 1) Pedroia played for two months with various thumb injuries, which surely affected his swing and production. 2) Pedroia has ALWAYS swung hard, from his college career forward, and when healthy, has been a very good player, including being named MVP. 3) You give the media way too much credit; Youkilis wasn't shiped out of town because of the media; he was traded because Middlebrooks is a better player and Youkilis couldn't adapt to not playing every day.
Comment From Jim on the cape
We hear how much the Sox like Kalish. What is it that they l like? Not much power for a corner outfielder. Plays hard, of course. Did they misread Kalish vs. Reddick?
It will be interesting to see, Jim, on the Reddick-Kalish thing. For now, of course, Reddick has been the better player. It's tough to evaluate Kalish right now because he missed more than a year with the shoulderneck injuries. What do they like. His swing, plate discpline, athleticism and instincts.
Let's take three more
Comment From Tyrion Lannister
obviously its very difficult to get a front office job but have you ever considered a job in a front office? clearly you know your stuff.
Thanks, but you're giving me way too much credit there. There's a ton I don't know about scouting and evaluation, to name just a few areas. I have enormous respect for people who work in front offices. It's highly competitive, with incredibly long hours. And I'm happy doing what I'm doing.
Comment From Juan
Who do you see as as the next few homegrown players to step in and make an impact?
The Killer B's ass they've come to be known: OF Jackie Bradley Jr; RHP Matt Barnes and INF XAnder Bogaerts are the three most regarded prospects. There are others of course, but they're consideres the cream of the crop and are almost untouchable in deals.
Comment From Ill Have Another
has there ever been a time of more unrest than now in red sox history? even during the 86 yr drought people seemed to be less volatile towards the playersfront officeowners
I don't thnk this is the worst. Go back to the early 80s when the team wasn't keeping its free agents (Lynn, Fisk, etc) and there were ownership squabbles between Buddy Leroux and Haywood Sulliivan. That was pretty bad and it didn't follow two world championships, either.
That's going to do it for today, folks. Thanks to all for participating. I'm off next week, but we'll return in two weeks. Again, many thanks!
Live Chat Moderator:
Thanks Sean and thank you all for participating. If you missed anything, the transcript for the entire chat should be on CSNNE.com later today!